Modified medical research council scale vs baseline dyspnea index to evaluate dyspnea in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. The primary purpose of this study was to examine the validity and responsiveness of the selfadministered computerized sac versions of the multidimensional baseline dyspnea index bdi and the transition dyspnea index tdi. Minimally important differences in the mahlers transition. Numerous instruments have been developed to examine the impact of activities on breathlessness. Sep 23, 2009 the mahler baseline dyspnoea index bdi and tdi have recently been shown to be feasible, reliable and valid in patients with sscild 3, 4. Symptom selfreport is acknowledged to be the most valid and. Meaningful effect size and patterns of response of the. The index consists of 3 items, one for each category. Dyspnea at night paroxysmal nocturnal dyspnea paroxysmal nocturnal dyspnea pnd can occur in those with poor leftheart function. Impact of baseline and induced dyspnea on the quality of life.
Transition dyspnea index questionnaire definition 1. Scales such as the borg dyspnea scale,8 which aim to quantify perceptions, are generally. In any given individual, the tdi score represents either an improvement positive score or a worsening negative score compared with the bdi in the same individual. Transition dyspnea index how is transition dyspnea index. Peer, personal best peak flow if known by the patient, sao 2 in percentage, and mbs in fraction. Proceedings of the american thoracic society ats journals. Pdf modified medical research council scale vs baseline. What does transition dyspnea index questionnaire mean. One of the definitions of bdi is basal dyspnea index. Rates severity of dyspnea at a single point in time.
Jun 30, 2010 baseline dyspnea index bdi transitional dyspnea index tdi these two tools are often used in rehabilitation both as a measure of treatment outcome and to assess daily living activities see below. A baseline dyspnea index was developed to rate the severity ofdyspnea at a single state and a transition dyspnea index to denote changes from the baseline. Standard inventories to determine the association between level of activity and dyspnea are available. Three additional options in each category, which do not contribute to the scoring, allow circumstances in. Some patients present with acute worsening of chronic breathlessness that may be caused by a new problem or a worsening of the underlying disease eg, asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart failure. Mahler baseline dyspnea index definition of mahler. Mahler baseline dyspnea index mahler sign indication of thrombosis, with increase in. Baseline dyspnea index how is baseline dyspnea index. At baseline, dyspnea is often a component of a symptom cluster that includes depression and anxiety.
Determinants of baseline dyspnea were anxiety explained variance, 17%, maximum inspiratory pressure 4%, and pao 2 4%. Mahler baseline dyspnea index definition of mahler baseline. The most recent official statement of the american thoracic society on mechanisms, assessment, and management of dyspnea summarizes systematically the therapeutic interventions available for the treatment of dyspnea. To improve the clinical rating of dyspnea, we developed two new indexes that include the components of functional impairment and magnitude of effirt in addition to the magnitude oftask. The baseline dyspnea index bdi measures the severity of dyspnea at the baseline or the beginning of a clinical trial. At week 12, 60% of indacateroltreated patients had achieved a clinically meaningful reduction in dyspnea as defined by at least a 1point improvement in transition dyspnea index total score, as did 51% of the salmeterol group and 40% on placebo. More than 50% of respondents to a telephone survey reported that dyspnea limited sports and recreation activities as well as normal physical exertion. Among these tools, the baseline dyspnea index bdi has been. Re liabili ty and validi ty of dyspnea measures in. Evidence from functional brain imaging in copd mari herigstad, anja hayen, eleanor evans, frances m.
The transition dyspnea index tdi measures changes from this baseline transition period at subsequent visits. Although the evidence levels for each of those interventions vary greatly, they are listed in the present summary since it would. Individual members of the interviewing group varied with different patients, but the same two observers interviewed the same patient on both occasions. Patients who had a chief complaint of being short of breath or of experiencing dyspnea were shown an enlarged copy of the mbs and were asked to rate their dyspnea figure 1.
Baseline dyspnea index bdi transition dyspnea index tdi type of questionnairedescription. Modified borg informational guide for dyspnea scale management. Assessment and palliative management of dyspnea crisis richard a. Dec 19, 2014 an approach to acute dyspnea duration. A standardized rating scale developed by mahler et al in 1984, which is a general scale used to measure the rating of severity of dyspnea at a single state as baseline. Baseline dyspnea index rehabmeasures database abilitylab. The baseline dyspnea index bdi is used to rate the severity of dyspnea at a single point in time. What does baseline dyspnea index questionnaire mean. Baseline and transition dyspnea indexes bditdi official.
Evaluation of three scales of dyspnea in chronic obstructive. Reliability and validity of dyspnea measures in patients with obstructive lung disease. Thus, relief of dyspnea and its impact on disability is an important goal of therapy 1, 2. Started in 1995, this collection now contains 6769 interlinked topic pages divided into a tree of 31 specialty books and 732 chapters. The test is applicable to patients with dyspnea on exertion or at rest due to respiratory disease. Documentation on the ed record by the triage nurse included the following. Modified medical research council scale vs baseline dyspnea. Tdi is a multiple choice questionnaire that clinicians may use to denote dyspnea changes since baseline. It provides a multidimensional measurement of dyspnea based on 3 components that evoke dyspnea in activities of daily living, in symptomatic individuals. Each interview was performed separately, without knowledge of either.
To measure the degree of dyspnea during exercise, the visual analogue scale vas and the borg scale are used, 5,6 whereas the modified medical research council mmrc dyspnea scale, 7 oxygen cost diagram ocd, 8 and baseline dyspnea index bdi, 9 as well as the shortness of breath questionnaire sobq, developed at the university of. Re liabili ty and validi ty of dyspnea measures in patients. Intervieweradministered rating of severity of dyspnea at a single state. Dyspnea is a common and troublesome manifestation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease copd. The mahler baseline dyspnoea index bdi and tdi have recently been shown to be feasible, reliable and valid in patients with sscild 3, 4. Development of selfadministered versions of modified baseline and transition dyspnea indexes in copd. Dyspnoea index levels of shortness of breath sob 0no sob. A clinical measure of shortness of breath for determining exertion levels, which may be markedly increased in patients with pulmonary hypertension. The index consists of 3 items, one for each category, each rated in 5 grades from 0. The scores depend on ratings for three different categories.
Bdi is a multiple choice questionnaire that clinicians may use to provide an assessment of dyspnea. Impact of baseline and induced dyspnea on the quality of. Usefulness of the modified 010 borg scale in assessing. Transition dyspnea index tdi digital infuzion, inc. To improve the clinical measurement of dyspnea, we developed a baseline dyspnea index that rated the severity of dyspnea at a single state and a transition dyspnea index that denoted changes from that baseline. Modi ed medical research council scale vs baseline dyspnea. Ratings for each c the three categories are then summed to form a baseline total dyspnea scot bdi. Baseline dyspnea index bdi bladder control scale blcs bowel control scale bwcs brief pain inventoryinterference scale short form bpii brief pain inventoryinterference scale bpii brief psychiatric rating scaleanchored bprsa clinical dementia rating cdr.
A standardized rating scale developed by mahler et al in 1984, which is a general scale used to measure the changes in dyspnea severity from the baseline as established by the baseline dyspnea index bdi. A fiveitem scale that assesses age, wheezing, dyspnea. The lower the score, the worse the severity of dyspnea. The questionnaire contains 3 categories of 24 items. Breathing difficulty is the major reason that patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease copd seek medical attention. Validity and responsiveness of the selfadministered.
Dyspnea is the main symptom perceived by patients affected by chronic respiratory diseases. After lying down, fluid redistribution due to gravity demands more activity from the left and right sides of the heart. Instruments are available that can discriminate the level of breathlessness as well as evaluate dyspnea over time, including over the course of therapeutic interventions. At baseline, dyspnea in each of the three categories is rated on 5point scale ranging from 0 severe to 4 unimpaired. Dyspnea can only be rated by the individual experiencing it. Baseline and transition dyspnea index rehabmeasures database. It derives from a complex interaction of signals arising in the central nervous system, which is connected through afferent pathway receptors to the peripheral respiratory system airways, lung, and thorax. While the bdi, as its name indicates, constitutes the initial baseline assessment discriminative tool, the tdi is administered at a certain. Mahler baseline dyspnea index mahler sign indication of thrombosis, with increase in pulse rate and no elevation of temperature. The american thoracic society ats dyspnea scale is a selfreporting respira. Information about the openaccess article modified medical research council scale vs baseline dyspnea index to evaluate dyspnea in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in doaj. Dyspnoea index definition of dyspnoea index by medical.
Able to accomplish normal activities with frequent rest periods and some increase in baseline oxygen. Bditdi officially distributed by mapi research trust. Anxiolytics benzodiazepines varying study outcomes. The meaning of bdi abbreviation is basal dyspnea index. The modified medical research council mmrc scale, baseline dyspnea index bdi and the oxygen cost diagram ocd are widely used tools for evaluation of limitation of activities due to dyspnea in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease copd. The scores in both indexes depend on ratings for three different categories. Translation and validation of the multidimensional dyspnea12. In patients with mild to moderate copd forced expiratory volume in 1 second, 50% of predicted, the main determinant of healthrelated quality of life was anxiety explained variance, 43%. Baseline dyspnea index transitional dyspnea index bditdi. About 40% indicated that their breathing affected their ability to perform household.
1455 1394 1441 1362 563 570 522 269 590 748 1164 137 772 693 242 64 259 294 1469 270 307 1248 190 1480 1023 912 529 797 1482 367 1145 167 762 1307 1137 793 1292 75 224 595 818 807 1255 266 1449 1346